An outline of Islay, Scotland

Lagavulin 2005 Pedro Ximénez Cask Finish review

ProducerLagavulin
StyleSingle Malt Scotch
RegionIslay, Scotland
Age15 years
Price£86.95
ABV43%

Each year Diageo releases a limited run of Lagavulin Distillers Edition bottlings. Usually, Lagavulin uses their standard 16-year whisky as the base and finishes it in Pedro Ximénez sherry casks, however, this release uses a 15-year-old whisky as the base. Lagavulin says that these casks were selected to honour the flavour profile of that distilling year - meaning this expression isn't just Lagavulin 16 all dressed up.

The 2005 Distillers Edition is twice-matured; once in ex bourbon casks and then again in ex Pedro Ximénez sherry casks.

Nose

A big savoury nose. Lots of sea salt and seaweed, followed by robust warming spices. The fruit from the sherry cask adds a sweet and softening quality to and otherwise bold dram. There's a waxy leather note, and drying raisin bitterness. All this amongst the very typical earthy smoke and vegetal Islay nose.

Palate

Delicate, smokey, crisp, and spicy; not a combination of notes I'd usually expect to use when tasting an Islay dram! Lots of smoke, dark chocolate, and salty sea air. The smoke on the palate isn't as intense as the nose would suggest - it's light, like the smoke in the air on bonfire night. There's a little lemon zest towards the end. The oily and sticky texture from the Pedro Ximénez sherry stands out.

Finish

A long smokey finish. Vegetal and earthy. Whilst the slightly peppery finish fills the mouth, the delicate fruit and sticky sherry notes linger. This is a dram you'll taste on your breath for a while after it's gone!

Overall

There's not much else to say here, other than this is a great dram. I really enjoy the strong Pedro Ximénez notes I find in this bottling; I think they complement Lagavulin's soft smoke and delicate savoury notes well. My only real criticism is that the proof is low. Low for a special edition, anyway. For only circa ~£10 above the price of the standard 16-year the 2005 Distillers Edition is good value, too.


An illustration of Mike Kaperys

Mike Kaperys

Mike is an avid whisky enthusiast from Yorkshire, England. A software engineer by trade, he founded Mash Whisky in 2021 as a hobby project and learning exercise. Initially a fan of bourbon, Mike now finds himself reaching for Islay scotch more often than not. His current favorite cocktail is the New York Sour.

View all articles by Mike Kaperys »

Mash Whisky

Mash Whisky is an online whisky magazine and blog dedicated to reviews of scotch, bourbon, world whiskey and cocktails.

Follow @mashwhisky on Instagram